Brazilian Lawmaker Opposes Full Amnesty but Open to Lesser Penalties Debate

Hugo Motta, leader of Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies, stated there is no political support for a ’broad, unrestricted amnesty’ demanded by Bolsonaro allies for those involved in the January 8 anti-democratic riots. While rejecting blanket pardons, he acknowledged concerns over harsh sentences for peripheral participants, proposing case-by-case reviews for lighter penalties. Over 1,400 were arrested, with 141 still jailed and 44 under house arrest, per STF data.

Motta advocated for an alternative bill to address sentencing fairness, noting bipartisan openness to compromise. He also criticized Eduardo Bolsonaro’s refusal to return from the U.S., calling it harmful to national interests. Meanwhile, revelations of a foiled coup plot (’Punhal Verde Amarelo’) targeting Lula and Supreme Court justices added tension to the amnesty debate.

The lawmaker reiterated that personal agendas must not override Brazil’s stability, signaling potential talks with Lula and the STF on penal reforms. Opposition leaders, however, continue pushing amnesty as a priority, ensuring ongoing legislative clashes.

Hugo MottaAmnestyBolsonaroCâmara dos DeputadosJanuary 8 riotsBrazil politicsSTFLulaPenal ReformOpposition